But Clark is considerably more modest when assessing the comparison, insisting that Gascoigne was a generational talent whose career would have reached even greater heights without the serious injury he suffered after leaving Tottenham Hotspur for Lazio.
Indeed, Clark believes his former Newcastle teammate would have won the Ballon d'Or, potentially on more than one occasion, had circumstances been different.
Sherrard, whose research into Newcastle United's history has included revisiting matches from Clark's playing career, believes the midfielder deserves greater recognition for his contribution to the club.
He told Football Presse, "The one who would have assumed the mantle, if you like, would have been Lee Clark because Lee Clark, again, a Tyneside-born guy, came into a team that wasn't doing particularly well.
"I think Lee feels himself that it was probably easier to leave him out than to leave out a big signing at times. But in the process of writing the book, I'd rewatched quite a few games, and there are spells in those when you go, you've got to remind yourself that Lee Clark was a 20-year-old getting in front of the midfield, charging into the box and scoring some very valuable goals.
"He just had stamina and the will to keep playing that separated him from others.
"He was a little bit unfortunate as well that it was just the point when Newcastle would willingly spend an awful lot of money on players, and there's only a certain number of places in a team to go.
"Perhaps Lee, in another era, if he was a couple of years older, would have held them off because he'd been more established and more of a senior player.
"But he was the homegrown one who got closest and had a natural talent, a natural ability, and also a team ethic and something about him."
Asked about Sherrard's assessment, Clark immediately turned the conversation towards the player whose achievements he believes remain on another level.
"Well, that's some comparison because I always believed Paul was one of the best of his generation," Clark tells Football Presse.
"If he hadn't got the serious injury when he left Tottenham to go to Lazio, would have been a Ballon d'Or winner without a shadow of a doubt.
"Whoever you talk to, and they were lucky enough, especially at international level, but at club level, and they played with him, they'll all – if you ask any player who's been in his team to name the best player they've ever played with, Paul is unanimously the man that they talk about, and it doesn't even take a couple of seconds to think about."
Clark was several years younger than Gascoigne during their Newcastle days, but had the opportunity to watch the England international at close quarters as he emerged as one of the most exciting footballers in the country.
He remembers a player whose extraordinary ability was matched by a personality that made him popular with those around him.
"An absolute great lad, you know. I was a few years younger than him, but got to know him well.
"An absolute diamond of a guy, sensational footballer, and deep down a great fella."
One of Clark's most revealing memories concerns Gascoigne's relationship with the younger players at Newcastle. Already the first-team star, with clubs throughout Europe interested in signing him, he could easily have kept his distance from the youngsters coming through the club.
Instead, Gascoigne would regularly stay behind at the training ground until the younger players had finished their schoolwork and were ready to begin their sessions.
"Paul was in the first team, the star man at Newcastle United. Every club in Europe wanted him at the time, and before he eventually went to Tottenham.
"But he would stay back after training, wait at the training ground till about 6pm when we would start our sessions after our schoolwork, and he would join in the sessions with us.
"And it was just to have someone like him around us. Then, as I said, lucky enough to become a close friend of his. And just loved watching him.
"I think some of the things that he could do with the football and what he did do, both at club level and internationally."
It was that ability which made Gascoigne such a special footballer in Clark's eyes. His subsequent performances for Tottenham and England only reinforced what those who had watched him develop at Newcastle already knew.
Clark is particularly emphatic about the impact of the injury that interrupted Gascoigne's career after his move to Lazio, believing it denied football the opportunity to see just how far his talent could take him.
"To be even mentioned in the same breath as Paul is an honour. But certainly not, you know, I had a good career, I was a good player, but I was nowhere near the level of what Paul was because, as I said, one of the generational talents.
"And without the injury situation, would have possibly been the only one since Kevin Keegan to have won the Ballon d'Or on more than one occasion."
For Clark, the difficulties Gascoigne experienced after his playing career also need to be understood in the context of how important football had been to him throughout his life.
"He's had his, obviously, issues since he stopped playing, but I think that's very similar to a lot of us, you know. Football was so important to Paul.
"Once that wasn't around him 24/7, it was going to be difficult."
There is no mistaking the affection Clark retains for his former teammate. His memories are not simply of a footballer capable of extraordinary things with a ball, but of someone who made time for younger players and remained a great person away from the attention that surrounded his career.
Sherrard's comparison with Clark offers an interesting perspective on Newcastle's production of homegrown talent, but Clark is in no doubt about the distinction between the two footballers.
He enjoyed a successful career of his own, representing Newcastle and playing under some outstanding managers, but Gascoigne belonged to a different category.
For Clark, the question of what might have happened without that injury remains one of English football's great unanswered questions.
He believes Paul Gascoigne had the ability to become one of the greatest players the game has ever seen. And he is convinced the Ballon d'Or would have been part of that story.
