More than two months after joining the Dutch club, the 18-year-old is still waiting for his first competitive goal and has yet to establish himself in the starting line-up.
Manchester United included break clauses in the loan agreements of their young players, allowing the club to consider ending an arrangement during the January transfer window. Obi's lack of involvement means his future in the Netherlands is now under review.
Willem II's problems have made the situation particularly challenging. The club have lost nine and drawn three of their opening 12 league matches, leaving them at the bottom of the Eredivisie after winning promotion through the play-offs last season.
Obi has experienced some difficult results from the sidelines and on the pitch. He featured in a 3-0 defeat against Excelsior and a 5-1 loss to Ajax, while he was an unused substitute when PSV Eindhoven won 7-0.
The circumstances were always going to make his first loan challenging, but United had considered the Eredivisie a suitable environment for his development. The club wanted him to gain experience of senior football abroad rather than send him into the physical demands of the lower divisions in England.
Willem's technical director Freek Heerkens welcomed the signing by emphasising the opportunity for the teenager to take an important next step.
βChido is a young, talented striker who is at an important moment in his development,β he said.
βHe has been able to develop in a top-level sports environment at Manchester United over the past few years and is now eager to gain experience. We can help him with that, and the Eredivisie is an excellent platform for it.
βAt the same time, with Chido, our squad is bringing in a striker whose qualities can be of value to the team.β
Obi had previously made eight first-team appearances under Ruben Amorim during the 2024-25 season, but those opportunities came largely because of injuries elsewhere in the squad.
United subsequently decided that he needed further development before being considered a regular first-team option. He spent last season playing in academy football, scoring 20 goals and working on aspects of his game away from possession.
The club had hoped a loan would provide the next stage of that progress. However, Obi has struggled to convince Willem's coaching staff that he is ready to become a regular starter.
He has scored twice in behind-closed-doors friendlies, but those goals have not yet translated into competitive opportunities.
The coaching changes have added to the uncertainty. John Stegeman was dismissed after Obi's arrival, with Adrie Koster taking temporary charge before Jurgen Streppel was appointed.
Koster questioned the youngster's defensive responsibilities after a cup match in which Willem were reduced to ten men, although he was careful not to place the blame entirely on the teenager.
βIt is partly a matter of mindset, but also of youthful exuberance,β Koster said. βThat boy has never experienced anything like this before. He doesn't do it on purpose either, so we shouldn't focus everything on him. This is simply part of his learning process. But we are going to talk to him about it.β
The change of manager has not yet improved Obi's position. He was an unused substitute in both of Streppel's first matches, leaving United with a decision to make if the situation continues.
A January recall would not necessarily mean the end of his development. He could return to academy football for the second half of the season, although United would need to decide whether another loan arrangement would offer a better route forward.
Obi arrived from Arsenal in 2024 with a considerable reputation after an outstanding goalscoring record at youth level. His early senior appearances generated excitement, but the transition to regular men's football has proved more demanding.
United's immediate priority will be finding an environment where he can play. If Willem cannot provide those opportunities, an early return to Old Trafford may become the most practical option.
