The former France international believes the Chelsea full-back's difficulties contributed to the instability that affected Zinédine Zidane's side during the second half in Milan.
France had taken an early lead through Michael Olise, but Italy responded through Pio Esposito before goals from Davide Frattesi and a second from Esposito secured the victory.
The result exposed weaknesses in a French defence that had struggled to deal with Italy's attacking transitions, particularly down the flanks.
Gusto was given an opportunity to start after injuries to Jules Koundé and Pierre Kalulu, but his performance at San Siro came under scrutiny.
The 23-year-old had previously enjoyed a strong season with Chelsea, making 49 appearances in all competitions, but his position in the pecking order has become less secure under Xabi Alonso.
Lizarazu discussed the performance on Téléfoot, acknowledging that France's attacking approach had contributed to the problems but also pointing to the individual difficulties experienced by Gusto.
âVictory always gives you the right answers, while defeat reveals your weaknesses and allows you to perhaps work on them better. I have identified those weaknesses,â he said.
âThere was clearly a defensive problem in the second half. That problem is linked to several things. Because we play very high up the pitch and like to have the ball, we expose ourselves to counter-attacks.â
However, Lizarazu did not believe the collective explanation was enough to account for everything that went wrong.
âI still think Malo Gusto's individual failure played a part. I don't want to dwell on him because these things happen, but it inevitably unbalances a defence,â he added.
âOn his side, things were consistently fragile.â
The comments represent a pointed assessment of a player who had been handed an opportunity to strengthen his position in the national team.
France's defensive problems were not limited to one individual, with their high defensive line leaving space for Italy to exploit. Nevertheless, Lizarazu believes Gusto's struggles made the situation worse and affected the balance of the back four.
The defeat was France's first under Zidane, who had taken charge of the national team earlier in the year. The coach was therefore given an immediate reminder of the defensive work still required as he develops his preferred system.
France responded by beating TĂŒrkiye 2-1 in Bordeaux on Sunday, a result that confirmed their place in the Nations League quarter-finals.
Gusto will now have to respond at club level if he is to remain part of Zidane's plans. His previous performances for Chelsea demonstrated his potential, but Lizarazu's criticism has highlighted the need for greater defensive consistency when opportunities arrive with the national team.
