Football Presse

Premier League clubs agree to cover legal costs over Man City case

·By Paul Vegas
Share
Premier League clubs agree to cover legal costs over Man City case

Manchester City/X.com

Premier League clubs have voted to cover the legal expenses of the organisation’s five board directors if Manchester City sponsors Etihad and Etisalat take legal action against them.

The proposal was approved by an 18-2 majority at a meeting in London on Thursday, with Manchester City and Nottingham Forest the only clubs to oppose the change.

It follows threats from City’s commercial partners after an independent commission found the club guilty of breaching financial regulations through sponsorship arrangements that it ruled were not genuine.

Manchester City have appealed against the commission’s findings and continue to deny wrongdoing. No sanction has yet been determined.

The league’s existing articles of association provide financial protection for a director if they successfully defend a legal case brought against them by a third party. The rules did not, however, provide the same protection if the director lost.

The amendment will extend that indemnity to chief executive Richard Masters, chair Alison Brittain and three non-executive directors: Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder.

The decision means the clubs collectively could be responsible for legal expenses arising from claims against the five individuals in connection with their work for the Premier League.

The issue has emerged after Etihad Airways and telecommunications company Etisalat indicated that they were considering legal action against the league.

Both companies were referenced in the independent commission’s findings concerning Manchester City’s commercial arrangements. The sponsors have rejected any suggestion that they were involved in improper deals.

Etihad said it categorically rejected findings or implications that the airline had participated in improper commercial arrangements. Etisalat described the commission’s verdict as entirely false and defamatory, adding that it was considering its legal options.

Manchester City’s chief financial officer, Ingo Bank, reportedly asked Brittain during Thursday’s meeting whether the proposed amendment was a direct response to the threats from the two sponsors. She declined to comment.

Nottingham Forest also voted against the proposal, although their objection was understood to be procedural rather than an expression of support for City.

The club reportedly felt insufficient information had been provided and that teams had not been given enough time to consider the potential financial consequences. Forest believed a decision carrying potentially significant responsibilities for all 20 clubs required greater scrutiny before a vote.

The dispute stems from the independent commission’s September findings, which concluded that City had artificially inflated their revenues by more than £830 million over a nine-year period.

The commission found that the club had arranged what it described as “sham” sponsorship contracts, disguising funding from its owners, the Abu Dhabi United Group.

Premier League chief executive Masters previously said City had “systematically broke Premier League rules for nearly a decade”.

City have challenged the findings, maintaining that they are innocent and that the process contained significant errors. Their appeal remains ongoing, leaving the final outcome of the case unresolved.

The latest vote creates an unusual situation in which City could potentially face financial consequences through the collective responsibility of the other clubs if their own sponsors pursue claims against the league’s leadership.

With Etihad and Etisalat yet to decide whether to proceed, the immediate cost of the amendment remains uncertain. However, the clubs have now agreed that the five directors will have additional legal protection as the dispute continues.