Football Presse

Apollo abandons £1.5bn loan to Man City owners

·By Paul Vegas
Share
Apollo abandons £1.5bn loan to Man City owners

Manchester City/X.com

Manchester City’s financial troubles have taken on a new dimension after US investment group Apollo Global Management reportedly abandoned a planned £1.5billion loan to the club’s parent company.

The Financial Times reported that Apollo had been close to completing negotiations with City Football Group (CFG) in September, before the independent commission found Manchester City guilty of breaching Premier League financial regulations.

The ruling, which City are appealing, found that the club had artificially inflated its financial position by more than £900million over a nine-year period. The commission upheld the vast majority of the charges relating to alleged sham commercial arrangements.

Apollo’s withdrawal represents a significant setback for CFG, with the proposed financing understood to have provided additional liquidity and helped refinance existing credit facilities.

Neither Apollo nor City has publicly commented on the reported collapse of the negotiations.

The development follows another setback involving a separate City-related transaction. Bloomberg reported last week that German lender Oldenburgische Landesbank had withdrawn from a proposed arrangement involving Brazilian club Palmeiras.

The deal would have allowed Palmeiras to receive a substantial upfront payment against instalments owed by City for midfielder Allan Elias, who moved to the Etihad Stadium during the summer for £32million, with a further £2million in potential add-ons.

The bank was reportedly concerned about the financial and reputational risks associated with Manchester City.

The two developments suggest that the commission’s decision is already having consequences beyond the immediate footballing implications, despite the club's determination to challenge the findings.

City owner Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed al Nahyan injected £100million into the group in the month following the ruling. It was the first tangible indication that the verdict had prompted a financial response from Abu Dhabi.

Mansour, who has attended only one Manchester City home match since the takeover in 2008, has made no public statement about the conviction.

The ruling has also created uncertainty around the club’s wider commercial relationships. City have consistently denied wrongdoing and are preparing an appeal, but the outcome could have serious consequences if the commission’s findings are upheld.

A failed appeal would not necessarily end the legal battle. City could seek a judicial review at the High Court, although that route would require the club to establish that the Premier League acted outside its powers or reached a conclusion that no reasonable authority could have reached. Permission from the court would also be required, and the threshold is high.

There are already signs that the dispute could extend beyond the club itself. Premier League teams have voted to cover the legal expenses of five board directors if sponsors Etihad and Etisalat pursue claims against them.

The protection covers chief executive Richard Masters, chair Alison Brittain and three other non-executive directors. The potential legal action follows the commission’s findings, which have created the prospect of sponsors challenging the way their commercial arrangements were characterised.

Financial analyst Paul Quinn, writing on The Esk website, argued that Apollo’s concerns were directed at City Football Group rather than Abu Dhabi itself. That distinction is significant given Apollo recently agreed to take a minority stake in Mubadala Capital, the sovereign wealth fund chaired by Mansour and run by City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak.

Quinn also questioned CFG’s ability to fund itself, despite Manchester City’s substantial revenues. The group’s pre-tax loss widened from £122.2million to £292.3million in the last financial year.

Manchester City generated £694.1million of CFG’s £888million revenue, yet recorded a £9million loss.

The reported withdrawal by Apollo therefore adds pressure at a time when City are already confronting the financial and reputational consequences of the Premier League case. Their appeal remains the immediate priority, but the lending market’s response suggests the uncertainty is reaching well beyond the courtroom.