The 21-year-old joined the Premier League club on deadline day in September, with Brighton securing his services after a reported fee of around €23 million. His departure has since prompted questions inside VfB Stuttgart, where the central midfield position has proved a problem during the current campaign.
According to a report by Bild, not everyone at the Bundesliga club understood the decision to allow Andrés to leave.
The Spanish midfielder had made a strong impression during his season in Germany, establishing himself as an important option after arriving from Real Madrid in 2025. He made 41 appearances in all competitions for Stuttgart, contributing four goals and two assists.
His performances helped the club qualify for the Champions League and reach the DFB-Pokal final.
Brighton moved late to secure the midfielder, offering him the opportunity to continue his development in the Premier League. He has since settled alongside experienced midfielder Pascal Groß and has been part of a team enjoying an impressive campaign under Fabian Hürzeler.
Brighton's position near the top of the Premier League table has only intensified the debate about Stuttgart's decision.
The Bundesliga side have experienced difficulties in central midfield this season, with injuries forcing them to turn to younger options. Nineteen-year-old Yanik Spalt has been among those asked to step in.
The financial details of Andrés' departure also mean Stuttgart did not retain the entire transfer fee. Real Madrid had negotiated a 50 per cent sell-on clause when the midfielder left their academy for Germany, giving the Spanish club a substantial share of the Brighton payment.
Stuttgart's sporting director Fabian Wohlgemuth previously acknowledged that the club would have preferred to keep Andrés from a footballing perspective, but said the player's desire to move and the financial conditions of the offer had to be considered.
The question now is whether Stuttgart will regret losing a midfielder who has quickly demonstrated his ability to make an impact in English football.
