Football Presse

Premier League board seeks legal protection over Man City case

·By Paul Vegas
Share
Premier League board seeks legal protection over Man City case

Manchester City/X.com

The Premier League's board is asking its 20 member clubs to provide legal protection for chief executive Richard Masters and four fellow directors amid the possibility of legal action from Manchester City sponsors.

The proposal would see clubs collectively cover legal expenses and potential damages arising from third-party claims against the league's board members.

The issue is expected to be discussed at a meeting of all 20 clubs on Thursday, November 19. According to reports, the board has circulated a document seeking approval for wider indemnity arrangements that could apply even if a director loses a legal case.

The development comes after an independent commission found Manchester City had artificially inflated their revenue by approximately £900 million through sponsorship arrangements described as sham contracts.

The findings relate to commercial deals involving City between 2009 and 2018. The club deny wrongdoing and have appealed the commission's decision.

Two of City's principal sponsors have since indicated that they are considering their legal options.

Etihad Airways, the club's stadium and shirt sponsor, responded to the findings by saying it was considering legal action against the Premier League. The airline strongly rejected any suggestion that it had been involved in improper commercial arrangements.

Etisalat, another major City sponsor, also criticised the findings relating to its commercial relationship with the club. The telecommunications company described them as entirely false and defamatory and said it was considering its legal options.

The Premier League's board consists of Masters, chair Alison Brittain and non-executive directors Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC.

The current arrangements reportedly provide for a director's legal expenses to be reimbursed only if they win a case. The proposed changes would extend that protection, with clubs potentially assuming responsibility for costs and damages arising from third-party claims.

A document sent to clubs ahead of Thursday's meeting reportedly makes no direct reference to Manchester City, Etihad Airways, Etisalat or the ongoing financial case.

Nevertheless, the timing has prompted speculation that the proposal is connected to the sponsors' threats of legal action.

The potential financial exposure could be considerable, particularly if a corporate defamation claim were pursued outside the United Kingdom. The possibility of proceedings in the United States has also been raised, where legal costs can be substantial.

The league has declined to comment on the proposal.

For the clubs, the issue is whether they should collectively accept responsibility for protecting the league's directors from legal action arising from their official duties.

The request places the Premier League in an unusual position. Its board is seeking wider protection at a time when the league's handling of one of its most significant disciplinary cases has prompted strong objections from companies connected to the club at the centre of the investigation.

The proposal is due to be considered by the clubs this week, but no decision has yet been announced.