The Ecuador international has made a strong impression since arriving from Bayer Leverkusen, initially on loan, before Arsenal activated their option to complete a permanent transfer.
Hincapie, 24, has established himself as an important part of Arteta's defensive plans, offering versatility across the back line. His ability to operate at centre-back and left-back has made him a valuable option as Arsenal compete across several competitions.
According to BBC Sport, negotiations over an improved agreement are at an advanced stage. Hincapie is expected to sign a 12-month extension, despite having more than four years remaining on his existing contract.
The proposed renewal would reward the defender's progress and strengthen Arsenal's position against potential interest from elsewhere.
Hincapie's development has been particularly important given the demands on Arsenal's defence. His adaptability has allowed Arteta to adjust his back line without losing the balance and quality required to compete at the highest level.
The club are also planning to open discussions with Riccardo Calafiori over a new contract.
The Italy international joined Arsenal from Bologna in 2024 and has become another important part of Arteta's defensive options. His existing agreement runs until the summer of 2029, but the club are keen to discuss an extension before his contract situation becomes more pressing.
Calafiori's ability to contribute both defensively and in possession has made him a significant part of the team's plans. Arsenal will want to ensure that his long-term future is settled as they continue to build a squad capable of challenging for major honours.
The discussions with Hincapie and Calafiori form part of a wider contract renewal programme at the Emirates Stadium.
Arsenal are also working to secure new agreements for Jurrien Timber, Declan Rice and goalkeeper David Raya. The club are keen to avoid uncertainty surrounding several influential players at the same time and reward those who have become central to Arteta's project.
Hincapie's proposed extension is the most advanced of the two defensive negotiations outlined in the latest report. Calafiori's discussions are expected to begin at a later stage.
No new agreement has yet been officially announced for either player, but Arsenal's intention is clear: they want to maintain continuity within a squad that has developed into one of the strongest in English football.
Securing Hincapie's signature would be another important step in that process, while the planned talks with Calafiori indicate that the club are already looking further ahead.
