The 19-year-old arrived in Italy from Real Madrid after a difficult period in Spain, where his involvement had diminished following his high-profile move for a fee exceeding €60 million.
A temporary move to Fiorentina was intended to give him the opportunity to continue developing in European football, and his performances during the opening months of the campaign have strengthened the case for the decision.
Mastantuono has scored four goals in 13 appearances in Serie A, establishing himself as an important part of the Fiorentina team and attracting attention from other clubs in Italy.
According to La Repubblica, Fiorentina are exploring the possibility of extending his loan for another season. The newspaper reports that the club's sporting project, the player's relationship with the supporters and their existing relationship with Real Madrid could all help their efforts.
However, Fiorentina would need to demonstrate that they can compete for European qualification. A place in continental competition would strengthen their argument for keeping Mastantuono and help persuade the player that another season in Florence would be beneficial.
The current agreement is a straight loan without a purchase option, meaning any extension would require a fresh agreement with Real Madrid.
Milan and Roma have also begun making enquiries about the Argentine's situation, according to the Italian report. Their interest adds another complication for Fiorentina, who will be keen to retain a player whose performances have made him increasingly important to the team.
Real Madrid will ultimately have a significant say in what happens next. The Spanish club remain responsible for the player's long-term future, and another season in Italy could offer Mastantuono further opportunities to develop before returning to the Bernabéu.
For now, his progress in Serie A has given Fiorentina reason to consider extending the arrangement, although the club's league position and the interest from other sides could influence the outcome.
