O'Reilly has started 45 of Crewe's 46 league games this season and won the club's player of the season award, accumulating 21 goal involvements — seven goals and 14 assists — across 49 appearances in all competitions.
No player in either League One or League Two this season has managed five or more goals, ten or more assists, and 60 or more chances created. O'Reilly is the only one, according to Opta.
The Daily Mail report Villa are open to a permanent sale at around £1 million, with funds earmarked to reinvest into Unai Emery's squad. O'Reilly joined Villa's academy at the age of seven and was part of the 2021 FA Youth Cup winning side, drawing comparisons with Phil Foden for his close control and technical ability.
Former manager Steven Gerrard drafted him into the first-team setup, but senior opportunities have been limited since, with loan spells in Spain with Real Union, MK Dons, and Shrewsbury Town preceding his current stint at Crewe.
Portsmouth hold an advantage in the race given their Championship status — Oxford United, relegated to League One this season, are a less attractive proposition for a player whose form arguably merits a step up. Bolton Wanderers and Huddersfield Town have also been linked.
The Republic of Ireland have also been monitoring O'Reilly's campaign, with his mother's background opening the door to international eligibility.
A permanent exit from Villa Park this summer appears the most likely outcome. Breaking into Emery's Champions League squad was always going to be a tall order, and at 22 with his value at its peak, the timing makes sense for both club and player.
O'Reilly was nominated for League Two player of the month in March — recognition that underlines just how consistent his output has been throughout a season that has significantly raised his profile.